The first leg of Phish's Summer 2012 tour provided its share of fine improvisational moments and some great musical highlights, but in my opinion, the real headline of the summer has been the commitment to diving deep into the band's storied catalog. In a (nowadays) rare moment of candor in the press, Page McConnell told Rolling Stone before the tour began that the band would be aiming to play 200 songs over the course of the summer. Taken at face value at the time, the comment didn't appear to be describe anything overly ambitious -- the band has routinely crossed the 200 song mark on a yearly basis during the 3.0 era, though the limited 2012 schedule did provide a small challenge to accomplish this feat.
Soon after the tour kicked off, it became clear that this was not just an off-the-cuff remark. The band had set that their sites and set out on a campaign to not only reach that goal, but to shatter it; leg one ended with 207 unique songs performed. While previous years followed a measured approach to adding songs to the repertoire, in 2012 the band seemed to trot out unplayed songs like it was their obligation.
I thought I'd visually compare the cumulative song totals, by show, to the trajectory of the other years in the Phish 3.0 era. This graph gives a feel for the pace at which songs were added to the playlist year over year. While the other years show a steep climb, but then a steadying of the repertoire (except of Halloween shows in 2009 and 2010) , the 2012 plot shows an increasing, purposeful climb all the way until the end of leg one.
So where do we go from here? Will we see 2012 debuts at the same rapid clip as Leg One? Using a linear projection function (orange line), I tried to show where we might end up at the end of leg two [333 unique songs] and a hypothetical (unannounced but heavily rumored) four show New Year's run [360 unique songs]. Then just for fun, I included the projection if the 2012 tour schedule had the same workload (48 shows) as 2009, the most heavy touring year in 3.0 -- at the pace they are on they would be approaching 495 unique songs!
While those number seem ambitious and the linear projection could probably be tweaked for accuracy after a few more shows, remember, Phish has accomplished what they already have in leg one with no new original debuts and only one new cover (Kenny Rogers' "The Gambler"). There have been 140 songs played since 2009 that haven't year seen performance in 2012, and the band hasn't been shy about reaching back to pre-3.0 material to round out this years' setlists.
Here are songs performed each year of 3.0 that haven't seen action in 2012 yet.
2009 | 2010 | 2011 |
Albuquerque | A Apolitical Blues | After Midnight |
All Down the Line | After Midnight | Albuquerque |
All Of These Dreams | Albuquerque | Anything But Me |
Anything But Me | All Of These Dreams | Army Of One |
Army of One | All That You Dream | Auld Lang Syne |
Auld Lang Syne | Army of One | Been Caught Stealing |
Blue Moon | Auld Lang Syne | Big Balls |
Bobby Jean | Beauty of My Dreams | Brian and Robert |
Brian and Robert | Bill Bailey Won't You Pls Come Home? | Cars Trucks Buses |
Cars Trucks Buses | Billie Jean Jam | Colonel Forbin's Ascent |
Casino Boogie | Brian and Robert | Come Together |
Catapult | Burn That Bridge | Destiny Unbound |
Colonel Forbin's Ascent | Cars Trucks Buses | Dog Faced Boy |
Crimes of the Mind | Cold Water | Esther |
Demand | Colonel Forbin's Ascent | Fast Enough for You |
Destiny Unbound | Day or Night | Fifty Ways To Leave Your Lover |
Dixie Cannonball | Destiny Unbound | Fly Famous Mockingbird |
Dog Faced Boy | Dixie Chicken | Glide |
Drums | Dog Faced Boy | Guy Forget |
Esther | Don't Bogart That Joint | Halfway to the Moon |
Fast Enough for You | Dr. Gabel | Harpua |
Fly Famous Mockingbird | Esther | Have Mercy |
Frankie Says | Fast Enough for You | Icculus |
Free Bird | Fat Man in the Bathtub | Instant Karma! |
Glide | Feats Don't Fail Me Now | Jam |
Glory Days | Fly Famous Mockingbird | Lifeboy |
Gone | Frankie Says | Mellow Mood |
Happy | Free Man in Paris | Monkey Man |
Happy Birthday | Gone | On Your Way Down |
Harpua | Halfway to the Moon | Rhymes |
Hello My Baby | Harpua | Rocket in My Pocket |
Highway to Hell | Have Mercy | Rocket Man |
How High the Moon | Heartbreaker | Round Room |
I Been Around | I Am the Walrus | Scents and Subtle Sounds |
I Just Want To See His Face | I Been Around | Sleep |
I Kissed a Girl | Idea | Sparks |
Icculus | In the Aeroplane Over the Sea | Sweet Adeline |
Invisible | Instant Karma! | The Ballad of Curtis Loew |
Let Me Lie | Jumpin' Jack Flash | The Curtain |
Lifeboy | Killing In The name | The Way It Goes |
Love You | Let Me Lie | Thunder Road |
Middle of the Road | Lit O Bit | Time Loves a Hero |
Mountains in the Mist | Llama Reprise | Twenty Years Later |
Mustang Sally | Look Out Cleveland | USA Storage Jam |
My Mind's Got a Mind of its Own | Love You | |
NO2 | Mellow Mood | |
Oh! Sweet Nuthin' | Mercenary Territory | |
On Your Way Down | Mountains in the Mist | |
Rip This Joint | My Mind's Got a Mind of its Own | |
Rocks Off | My Problem Right There | |
Scents and Subtle Sounds | Night Nurse | |
Secret Smile | NO2 | |
Shake Your Hips | Oh Atlanta | |
She Thinks I Still Care | Oh! Sweet Nuthin' | |
Sleep | Old Folks Boogie | |
Sleep Again | On Your Way Down | |
Soul Survivor | Pigtail | |
Stop Breaking Down | Ramble On | |
Sugar Shack | Rocket in My Pocket | |
Sweet Black Angel | Sailin' Shoes | |
Talk | She Caught the Katy | |
The Ballad of Curtis Loew | Sleep Again | |
The Connection | Spanish Moon | |
Time Turns Elastic | Spooky | |
Tomorrow's Song | Stairway To Heaven | |
Train Song | Sugar Shack | |
Tumbling Dice | Summer of '89 | |
Turd on the Run | Thank You | |
Twenty Years Later | The Ballad of Curtis Loew | |
Two Versions of Me | The Connection | |
Uncle Pen | The Rover | |
Ventilator Blues | Time Loves a Hero | |
When the Cactus is in Bloom | Time Turns Elastic | |
Windy City | Train Song | |
Tripe Face Boogie | ||
Twenty Years Later | ||
Uncle Pen | ||
Walfredo | ||
What Things Seem | ||
Whole Lotta Love | ||
Willin' |
Where do you think they will end up? What songs will we likely see? What are you wishing for?